Skip to main content
EVENT TRACKER
Keep track of rescheduled, canceled industry events with our COVID-affected event tracker - Powered by Snap Finance
Close
Sister Publication Links
  • Rubber & Plastics News
  • European Rubber Journal
tb-logo
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • OPINION
    • CORONAVIRUS
    • AUTO INDUSTRY
    • BUSINESS/FINANCIAL
    • COMMERCIAL TIRE
    • FACTORY FIXES
    • GOVERNMENT & LAW
    • INTERNATIONAL
    • MOTOR SPORTS
    • NEW PRODUCTS
    • RETAIL TIRES
    • SERVICE ZONE
    • SEMA/AAPEX
    • SMALL BUSINESS
    • TIRE MAKERS
    • SPONSORED CONTENT
    • COVID takes dealers for roller-coaster ride
      A year later, pandemic's full tire industry impact unclear
      Tire Cologne canceled; rescheduled until 2022
      New round of Paycheck Protection Program funding opens
    • DTM switches horses mid-stream; awards race tire contract to Michelin
      Icahn Auto trims fiscal 2020 operating loss despite 14% lower sales
      Oshkosh unit gets contract for new USPS local delivery vehicle
      Sumitomo adds treadwear-detection to 'Sensor Core' toolkit
    • F1 extends Pirelli's supply contract through 2024
      Titan eyes solid recovery in 2021 as ag sector rebounds
      4 Wheel Parts celebrates 60th anniversary with deals, promotions
      CarAdvise partnering with RepairSmith mobile repair services
    • Goodyear joins connected mobility pilot program in Ohio
      Michelin launches high-scrub, weight-sensitive X One Multi T trailer tire
      TRAC Intermodal redirects retread biz 100% in-house
      Giti rolling out range of GT Radial-brand urban/regional truck tires
    • USTMA joins coalition supporting passage of Equality Act
      McMahon's Best-One increases its minimum wage to $15
      Oshkosh unit gets contract for new USPS local delivery vehicle
      Conti recalling 94,000 Conti-, General-, Barum-brand LT/SUV tires
    • F1 extends Pirelli's supply contract through 2024
      Maxam adding multipurpose radial, solid OTR tires
      Goodyear names Patterson to lead Cooper integration efforts
      DTM switches horses mid-stream; awards race tire contract to Michelin
    • F1 extends Pirelli's supply contract through 2024
      DTM switches horses mid-stream; awards race tire contract to Michelin
      Bridgestone World Solar Challenge canceled due to pandemic restrictions
      Pirelli, Goodyear ink sedan racing series contracts in Canada, Europe
    • Snap-on debuts Triton-D10 diagnostic tool with scan, lab scope capabilities
      Maxam adding multipurpose radial, solid OTR tires
      Michelin launches high-scrub, weight-sensitive X One Multi T trailer tire
      Giti rolling out range of GT Radial-brand urban/regional truck tires
    • COVID takes dealers for roller-coaster ride
      Investment groups to acquire Mavis Tire network
      Vogue Tyre offers $75 rebate on set of 4 tires during March
      4 Wheel Parts celebrates 60th anniversary with deals, promotions
    • Snap-on debuts Triton-D10 diagnostic tool with scan, lab scope capabilities
      Pennzoil offering carbon-neutral lubricants for passenger cars
      Washington dealership uses new-school solution for recruiting auto techs
      Marinucci: Customers may ignore dangerous conditions
    • TIA seeking nominations for Tire Industry Hall of Fame
      SEMA survey shows resilient auto aftermarket in 2020
      SEMA scholarships and loan forgiveness now available
      WTC hosting webinar Jan. 20 on load-capacity standards
    • SEMA survey shows resilient auto aftermarket in 2020
      Trade groups oppose minimum wage increase proposal
      New stimulus package fixes PPP loan confusion
      Vaccine may usher sense of normalcy
    • Goodyear joins connected mobility pilot program in Ohio
      Titan eyes solid recovery in 2021 as ag sector rebounds
      Michelin launches high-scrub, weight-sensitive X One Multi T trailer tire
      Goodyear names Patterson to lead Cooper integration efforts
    • Sponsored By Yokohama Tire Company
      7 questions to ask consumers when they need tires for a crossover SUV
      Sponsored By Yokohama Tire Company
      Stocking Tires for Crossover SUVs
      Sponsored By AppointmentPlus
      Three Important Lessons Learned for the Tire Business During a Pandemic
      Sponsored By Yokohama Tire Company
      7 questions to ask consumers when they need tires for a crossover SUV
  • SHOP FLOOR
    • BALANCING
    • DEMOUNTING
    • SAFETY
    • TIRE REPAIR
    • TPMS
    • TRAINING
    • VEHICLE LIFTING
    • WHEEL TORQUE
    • Video: Balancing Tire
      Safety tips for wheel balancing
      An introduction to wheel balancing
      Wheel weights: Balancing form with function
    • Video: Demounting
      Tire changer types, tips and trends
      How to clear rim rust and corrosion
      An introduction to demounting, mounting and inflation
    • Video: Safety
      Customers
      Considerations for shop safety policies
      Introduction: Creating a culture of safety
    • Video: Tire Repair
      Essential tools, materials and equipment for tire repair
      An introduction to tire repair
      How to properly patch a puncture
    • Video: TMPS Service
      The life-saving work of TPMS
      An introduction to TPMS service
      The importance of proper relearn procedures
    • Video: Training
      Internship ideas to attract tech talent
      Choosing the right auto service tech school
      Intro: Finding and training technicians
    • Video:Vehicle Lifting
      The gravity of proper lift points
      Safety essentials when using jack stands
      An introduction to lifts and lift safety
    • Video: Wheel Torque
      The importance of torque specifications
      Introduction to proper wheel installation
      Torque check and recheck recommendations
  • Multimedia
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS
    • PODCASTS
  • Events
    • ASK THE EXPERT
    • LIVESTREAMS
    • WEBINARS
    • SEMA LIVESTREAMS
  • Data
    • DATA STORE
  • Resources
    • DIRECTORY
    • CLASSIFIEDS
  • ADVERTISE
  • DIGITAL EDITION
  • Awards
    • Tire Dealer Humanitarian Award
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. News
April 03, 1995 02:00 AM

FATALLY FLAWED?: GOODYEAR FRANCHISEES' CASE IN DOUBTEXPERTS

Gregory James Kennedy and Steve Walters
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print

    AKRON-Out of the pages that constitute Goodyear's franchise agreement and G-110 dealer contract, it might be one simple sentence that decides the fate of two lawsuits filed against the tire maker by some of its Texas and California franchisees. It appears, according to two attorneys who specialize in franchise lawsuits, that the franchisees who filed the suits will have a tough time convincing courts that, as they contend, Goodyear infringed on its contractual and implied agreements when it began distributing tires through discounters and mass merchandisers, like Sears, Roebuck and Co. and Scottsdale, Ariz.-based Discount Tire Co.

    Last June, Goodyear franchise and contract dealers in California filed what they hope will become a class-action lawsuit alleging just that. Seven months later, a group of Texas dealers filed a similar suit in their state.

    These legal actions bring to light a growing friction between franchisees and their suppliers over changes in product distribution strategies. Similar lawsuits have been filed against Burger King Corp., Holiday Inns Inc. and Haagen-Dazs Co. Inc.

    Devoid of virgin market territory, many large franchisers are turning to non-traditional channels of distribution to boost sales, said Francine Lafontaine, an associate professor of business at the University of Michigan.

    As companies turn to non-traditional distribution channels, including mass merchandisers, discounters and electronic malls on the information superhighway, many of their traditional dealers have come to fear losing their own market share in the face of new and unexpected competition.

    The root of the problem is not difficult to understand, according to Philip F. Zeidman, a founder of the Washington, D.C.-based law firm Brownstein, Zeidman and Lore, and general counsel to the International Franchise Association.

    ``Many older (franchise) agreements were written before people thought of alternate channels of distribution. Therefore, there are some contracts which are ambiguous,'' Mr. Zeidman said.

    ``In the newer contracts, as people have become more adapted to the notion that alternate channels of distribution are clearly essential to many types of marketing, (those channels are) increasingly being provided for in franchise and license and distribution arrangements.''

    Specifically, courts have looked at the contract language to determine whether a franchiser reserved the right to open additional distribution outlets in a marketing area, Mr. Zeidman said.

    The Goodyear franchise agreement attached as Exhibit A in both the California and Texas petitions states: ``Goodyear retains the right to sell to other customers in dealer's trade area and elsewhere.''

    The G-110 contract agreement provided as an exhibit in both petitions states: ``Goodyear retains the right to establish its own outlets for the sale of Goodyear products or to sell Goodyear products to other customers in dealer's trade area or elsewhere.''

    That language strongly suggests a court would favor Goodyear in an alternate site dispute, according to attorney Lee Wilkins of the Texas law firm Cantey & Hanger L.L.P. Mr. Wilkins, who specializes in franchise suits, also is a member of the International Franchise Association.

    But while the attorneys for the Texas Goodyear dealers said they believe alternate site issues ``could become an issue'' in their suit, other allegations state Goodyear presented dealers with ``misleading'' information about their intentions to begin distributing through mass merchandisers and discount stores, causing the dealers to enter into contracts they might otherwise have rejected.

    A ``negligent misrepresentation theory'' is a cause of action in Texas, according to Mr. Wilkins. ``(But) Goodyear doesn't have a lot to worry about in that kind of case,'' he said. ``Proving damages under a negligent misrepresentation theory is traditionally pretty difficult in Texas.''

    During an interview, Mr. Wilkins spelled out what he considers the best arguments for both Goodyear and the dealers.

    ``The most favorable argument for Goodyear on this is that Goodyear has just recognized reality, which is: The lower the overhead of the reseller, the more Goodyear tires that can be sold. And they have located resellers such as Sears, Discount Tire and the like that have lower overhead.''

    Goodyear flatly denies any wrongdoing alleged in the California lawsuit and said each of the dealer plaintiffs ``has signed a contract expressly acknowledging Goodyear's right to sell its product to anyone.''

    But Mr. Wilkins said he understood the ``tough spot'' Goodyear's franchised dealers have found themselves in since the change in distribution strategy.

    He said the franchisees' best argument seems to be: ``Well, I have spent considerable time contributing to your advertising.*.*.* (and) creating demand for Goodyear (tires), which otherwise would not have been there but for my effort and my advertising dollars. And you sort of owe it to me not to let somebody else in buying tires who is kind of riding on my coattails.''

    So who wins?

    ``I really can't predict whether (the franchisees) are going to be able to make a case that's going to get them big damages-or even make a case that establishes liability-because of the scope of the contract, giving a non-exclusive territory allowing Goodyear to sell through other means,'' Mr. Wilkins said. ``But I am frankly glad to see the dealers not roll over.''

    The most likely end result will be slight changes in Goodyear's marketing strategies, such as the Akron-based tire maker's recent announcement that it will begin providing specific tire lines solely for dealers, Mr. Wilkins predicted. Similar franchisee cases have been settled through marketing changes or monetary compensation, according to Messrs. Zeidman and Wilkins.

    ``Goodyear is going to have to either make some changes in the way they distribute tires, i.e. quit distributing through Sears, Discount Tire and the like and go back to the dealer organization, or they are going to have to basically figure a lot of dealers are going to desert them,'' Mr. Wilkins said.

    But a number of securities analysts who follow the tire industry said they believe Goodyear was aware of the rift its new distribution strategy could cause in its existent dealer network.

    Harry Millis of Fundamental Research Inc. said Goodyear has increased its U.S. replacement market share about 2 percent through mass merchandisers, although he had expected a boost of about 3 percent.

    The tire manufacturer has done the volume it expected through the mass merchandisers, but the less-than-anticipated market share could be an indication of ``attrition in traditional areas,'' Mr. Millis theorized.

    ``Mass merchandising definitely has been a plus for Goodyear and its shareholders,'' Mr. Millis said. ``It has been a key part of Goodyear's earnings rebound.''

    If tire makers like Goodyear are finding alternate distribution channels to be beneficial to business, franchised dealers can expect increasingly intense competition in their market areas, Mr. Wilkins said, and strongly advised franchisees and potential franchisees to pay more attention to exclusivity clauses in their contracts.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Do you have an opinion about this story? Do you have some thoughts you'd like to share with our readers? Tire Business would love to hear from you. Email your letter to Editor Don Detore at [email protected].

    SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTERS
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please verify captcha.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    Newsletter Center

    Staying current is easy with Tire Business delivered straight to your inbox.

    SUBSCRIBE TODAY

    Subscribe to Tire Business

    SUBSCRIBE
    Connect with Us
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • RSS

    Our Mission

    Tire Business is an award-winning publication dedicated to providing the latest news, data and insights into the tire and automotive service industries.

    tb-logo
    Reader Services
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Site Map
    • Industry Sites
    • Order Reprints
    • Customer Service: 877-320-1716
    Partner Sites
    • Rubber & Plastics News
    • European Rubber Journal
    • Automotive News
    • Plastics News
    • Plastics News China
    • Urethanes Technology
    RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    • Terms of Service
    • Media Guide
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Classified Rates
    • Digital Edition
    • Careers
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • OPINION
      • CORONAVIRUS
      • AUTO INDUSTRY
      • BUSINESS/FINANCIAL
      • COMMERCIAL TIRE
      • FACTORY FIXES
      • GOVERNMENT & LAW
      • INTERNATIONAL
      • MOTOR SPORTS
      • NEW PRODUCTS
      • RETAIL TIRES
      • SERVICE ZONE
      • SEMA/AAPEX
      • SMALL BUSINESS
      • TIRE MAKERS
      • SPONSORED CONTENT
    • SHOP FLOOR
      • BALANCING
      • DEMOUNTING
      • SAFETY
      • TIRE REPAIR
      • TPMS
      • TRAINING
      • VEHICLE LIFTING
      • WHEEL TORQUE
    • Multimedia
      • VIDEOS
      • PHOTOS
      • PODCASTS
    • Events
      • ASK THE EXPERT
      • LIVESTREAMS
      • WEBINARS
      • SEMA LIVESTREAMS
    • Data
      • DATA STORE
    • Resources
      • DIRECTORY
      • CLASSIFIEDS
    • ADVERTISE
    • DIGITAL EDITION
    • Awards
      • Tire Dealer Humanitarian Award