Current Issue

GM dismisses 15 employees as 'deeply troubling' recall probe released

Comments Email
(Crain News Service photos)
Mary Barra

By Nick Bunkley and Mike Colias, Crain News Service

DETROIT (June 6, 2014) — General Motors Co. has dismissed 15 employees, including at least eight executives, after an internal investigation found “a pattern of incompetence and neglect” that led to 11 years of delays in recalling millions of cars for a fatal defect related to flawed ignition switches, CEO Mary Barra said June 5.

The investigation found that GM employees at many levels failed to recognize that cars shutting off posed a safety risk by disabling the airbags, neglected to share information about complaints and crashes, treated problems as someone else’s responsibility to fix and ignored data showing evidence of a possible defect.

It concludes there was no intentional cover-up and that cost was never prioritized over safety but cites numerous instances when employees—particularly one engineer who has now been fired—made decisions now known to have “tragic results.”

A 315-page report by former federal prosecutor Anton Valukas says GM categorized reports of cars stalling as a matter of customer “convenience” rather than one that could lead to crashes or deaths. It says a 2005 service bulletin sent to dealers was specifically worded to avoid attracting attention from federal safety regulators, and that GM lawyers agreed to settle a lawsuit in 2013 for $5 million, the maximum they were permitted without seeking approval from higher-ups.

The report says GM lacked urgency even as recently as December, when the trio of executives who voted on whether to issue recalls was first informed of the issue but was not told it was linked to any deaths.

Speaking to employees June 5, Ms. Barra promised that the company would address future safety issues far differently, warning that failing to report risks would make them “part of the problem” and even inviting them to contact her directly if they couldn’t get potential defects addressed themselves.

She also confirmed plans to set up a compensation fund for people affected by crashes related to the ignition switch, though details about the plan have not been finalized yet. GM said claims would be accepted beginning around Aug. 1.

Another five GM employees have been disciplined as a result of the company’s handling of the recall, GM said.

New committee

GM Chairman Tim Solso said in a statement June 5 that the board of directors will create a stand-alone committee to oversee “risk-management” issues. He also said the report concluded that Ms. Barra, President Dan Ammann and global product-development chief Mark Reuss did not learn of the ignition switch matter until December, shortly before the decision was made to issue a recall.

“The board, like management, is committed to changing the company’s culture and processes to ensure that the problems described in the Valukas report never happen again,” Mr. Solso said in the statement.

Ms. Barra called Mr. Valukas’ report “extremely thorough, brutally tough and deeply troubling.” She said engineers and others who learned of problems with ignition switches as early as 2003 “misdiagnosed the problem from the very beginning” and failed to treat it with the appropriate level of urgency.

Ms. Barra did not identify the employees who were fired or resigned.

Two engineers who had been suspended with pay since April 10 — Ray DeGiorgio, who designed the ignition switch, and Gary Altman, the program engineering manager for the Chevrolet Cobalt — are among them, two persons familiar with the matter said. Neither Mr. DeGiorgio nor Mr. Altman have commented publicly on their situations.

GM also ousted Bill Kemp, a senior lawyer who was responsible for safety issues within its legal department, as the auto maker reforms the operations that failed to address defective parts linked to 13 deaths, two persons familiar with the matter said.

Two former directors of product investigations, Carmen Benavides and Gay Kent, also are out, a person familiar with the matter said. The Valukas report notes that interviews with Ms. Benavides and Ms. Kent revealed that there was concern while writing a 2005 service bulletin to dealers that using the word “stall” might spur regulators to investigate whether a safety issue was involved.

Ms. Barra said most or all of the dismissed employees worked in the engineering, legal, public policy and quality departments and that more than half were senior-level executives. Five additional employees have been disciplined, she said.

Compensation fund

GM executives said the eligibility rules for the compensation fund would be set by attorney Ken Feinberg, meaning he could decide to count deaths that are not among the 13 that GM has tallied.

Dan Ammann, Mary Barra and Mark Reuss address GM employees.

Mr. Ammann said victims or the families of those killed could opt out of the fund and choose to pursue a traditional lawsuit but that if they do they will have “the same legal rights that they do today.”

That means GM could assert in court that it is not liable for pre-bankruptcy crashes. Ten of the 12 deaths identified by Automotive News and many of the non-fatal crashes occurred before GM’s bankruptcy.

GM in May admitted breaking federal law and agreed to pay a $35 million fine levied by NHTSA. It also has to meet with NHTSA officials monthly to discuss potential safety issues and implementation of the changes recommended by Valukas’ report.

The fatalities

GM is not releasing the names of the 13 people killed in crashes it links to faulty ignition switches, but Automotive News has identified 12 of them independently through GM documents, public records and interviews.

This list also includes two fatalities that were not among the 13 counted by GM: Natasha Weigel, who was a rear-seat passenger, and Brooke Melton, who died in a side-impact collision. A lawsuit connected with the Melton case led to the ignition switch recall.

Except where noted, the victim was the driver.

1. Shara Lynn Towne, 37

Date of accident: July 4, 2004

Site of accident: Visalia, Calif.

Vehicle: 2004 Saturn Ion

Seat belt: Yes

Alcohol: No

Speed: Unknown in a 45 mph zone

Ignition mode: Unknown*

Legal status: Settled with GM in Sept. 2007

Car veered off right side of road into utility pole.

2. Gene Mikale Erickson, 25 (front passenger)

Date of accident: Nov. 15, 2004

Site of accident: Van Zandt County, Texas

Vehicle: 2004 Saturn Ion

Seat belt: No

Alcohol: No

Speed: Unknown in a 40 mph zone

Ignition mode: Unknown*

Legal status: Settled with GM in July 2008

Car went off left side of road at slight curve and hit tree. Driver tested positive for Xanax and methamphetamine, pleaded guilty to negligent homicide and was sentenced to probation.

3. Amber Marie Rose, 16

Date of accident: July 29, 2005

Site of accident: Dentsville, Md.

Vehicle: 2005 Chevrolet Cobalt

Seat belt: No

Alcohol: 0.17% blood alcohol content

Speed: 69 mph in a 25 mph zone

Ignition mode: Accessory

Legal status: Settled with GM in Feb. 2006

Car went through end of residential cul-de-sac and hit tree.

4. Amy Rademaker, 15 (front passenger)

Natasha Weigel, 18 (rear passenger)

Date of accident: Oct. 24, 2006

Site of accident: St. Croix County, Wis.

Vehicle: 2005 Chevrolet Cobalt

Seat belt: No

Alcohol: No

Speed: 50 mph in a 55 mph zone

Ignition status: Accessory

Legal status: Lawsuit filed in March 2014

Car went off road, vaulted into air and hit a telephone junction box before striking two trees. Driver had only a learner’s permit with no licensed driver in the car. GM does not count Weigel’s death in its tally because she was sitting in the back seat, where there was no airbag.

5. Amy Wahl Breen, 42

Date of accident: Oct. 16, 2007

Site of accident: Lyndhurst, Ohio

Vehicle: 2005 Chevrolet Cobalt

Seat belt: Yes

Alcohol: No

Speed: 75 mph in a 35 mph zone

Ignition mode: Run

Legal status: No known lawsuit

Car went off right side of road and hit signpost, garbage cans, tree and guardrail.

6. Joseph Harding Jr., 19

7. Zachary Schoenbach, 19 (front passenger)

Date of accident: Sept. 13, 2008

Site of accident: Lincoln Township, Mich.

Vehicle: 2006 Chevrolet Cobalt SS

Seat belt: Harding yes, Schoenbach no

Alcohol: Harding had 0.12% BAC

Speed: 85 mph in a 45 mph zone

Ignition mode: Run

Legal status: No known lawsuit

Car went off left side of road on curve and hit tree.

8. Marie Sachse, 81

Date of accident: Feb. 4, 2009

Site of accident: St. Charles County, Mo.

Vehicle: 2004 Saturn Ion

Seat belt: Yes

Alcohol: No

Speed: Unknown in a 55 mph zone

Ignition mode: Unknown*

Legal status: GM settled in bankruptcy

Car veered off right side of road and hit tree.

9. Esther Matthews, 73

10. Grace Elliott, 13 (front passenger)

Date of accident: April 2, 2009

Site of accident: Clarion County, Pa.

Vehicle: 2005 Chevrolet Cobalt

Seat belt: No

Alcohol: No (driver of oncoming car had 0.24% BAC)

Speed: 47 mph in a 55 mph zone

Ignition mode: Accessory

Legal status: Lawsuit filed in May 2014

Car was struck head-on by a drunken driver who crossed center line of road. Driver of oncoming car also died.

11. Hasaya Chansuthus, 25

Date of accident: Dec. 31, 2009

Site of accident: Rutherford County, Tenn.

Vehicle: 2006 Chevrolet Cobalt SS

Seat belt: Yes

Alcohol: 0.19% BAC

Speed: 70 mph in a 70 mph zone

Ignition mode: Off

Legal status: GM settled in March 2011

Car hydroplaned on wet freeway, sideswiped another car and veered off right side of pavement into tree.

Brooke Melton, 29

Date of accident: March 10, 2010

Site of accident: Paulding County, Ga.

Vehicle: 2005 Chevrolet Cobalt

Seat belt: Yes

Alcohol: No

Speed: Unknown

Ignition mode: Accessory

Legal status: GM settled in September 2013

Car lost control on wet road and was broadsided by another vehicle. GM does not count Melton’s death as linked to the ignition-switch defect because it was a side-impact crash, but the lawsuit filed by her parents led to the eventual recall.

12. Dany Dubuc-Marquis, 23

Date of accident: June 22, 2013

Site of accident: Granby, Quebec

Vehicle: 2007 Chevrolet Cobalt SS

Seat belt: No

Alcohol: Unknown

Speed: Unknown

Ignition mode: Accessory

Legal status: Lawsuit filed in March 2014

Car went off road and struck multiple trees.

*The black-box module in the Saturn Ion does not record whether the ignition is not in “run.”

Source: Fatality Analysis Reporting System and Automotive News research


Lutz theorizes

Bob Lutz, the former GM vice chairman who headed product development, said last night during a dinner event at Eastern Michigan University that it was his belief that high turnover and lack of communication in the company caused the faulty ignition switches to go unnoticed.

Mr. Lutz said each department in the company likely knew small aspects of the problem, but employees never came together to look at the big picture.

The Department of Transportation’s inspector general is also investigating NHTSA for its handling of the recall and why the agency failed to detect it sooner.  

GM also faces another round of hearings in Congress and additional investigations by the Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Mr. Valukas wrote: “Those outside GM, including, in 2007, a trooper from the Wisconsin Safety Patrol and a research team from Indiana University, figured out the connection between the switch and the airbag non-deployment. Yet, GM personnel did not.”


Reporter Nora Naughton and Bloomberg News contributed to this report, which appeared on, the website of Automotive News, a Detroit-based sister publication of Tire Business.

More Polls>

TB Reader Poll

Previous | Published May 21, 2018

With one-third of 2018 in the books, how would you characterize business thus far?

Sales are behind where we were last year at this point.
29% (36 votes)
Our sales are about the same as last year.
20% (25 votes)
The first four months have been extremely strong; let's hope we can maintain it.
33% (41 votes)
One month up, one month down ...
18% (22 votes)
Total votes: 124
More Polls »